Ok, I simply cannot decide which one I like better. So, there are 3 semi-winners.
I modified your design a tiny bit to make it more bottom-heavy, but in general your design was the closest to my current theme. It was very white with simple outlines, which fits well with my other sprites. Also, it has a "classic" pixil art feel to it, which I like.
Since you both contributed to the same rock, I'll declare you co-co-winners
. I like the dithering, and if I modify my other sprites to be a bit less white, I will probably use your design.
All 3 get 5 MaxCoins and a boost on the Loom Special Thanks list. Thanks very much to everyone who entered and offered feedback. Your input will help make this game better.
There may be more contests soon as I come to need other things, so check back often